Butt Plugs

Shop butt plugs and anal plugs for gay men, comfort, control, and confident anal play.

Sort by

Most relevant
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old

View as List Grid

Perfect Fit
XPLAY Finger Grip Plug (3 sizes)

Regular priceFrom $42.95
Topped Toys
Deep Space 80 Plug

Blue Red Obsidian

Regular priceFrom $111.00
Topped Toys
Gape Keeper 108 Plug

Red Blue

Regular priceFrom $150.00
Topped Toys
The Grip 96 Plug

(2)

Red Blue

Regular priceFrom $110.00
Topped Toys
The Grip 126 Plug

Blue Red

Regular priceFrom $165.00
Sport Fucker
Thunder Plug Asslock

Black Blue Red

Regular price $77.95
Topped Toys
The Grip 70 Plug

(1)

Blue Red

Regular priceFrom $65.00
Topped Toys
Lotus 80 Plug

Red Blue Obsidian

Regular priceFrom $75.00
Spartacus
Blown Glass Butt Plug

Regular priceFrom $37.95
Landco
Erica Vibrating Butt Plug

Regular price $24.95
Doc Johnson
The Classic Butt Plug

Beige Black
Very low stock (1 unit)

Regular priceFrom $23.95
Topped Toys
The Grip 80 Plug

Blue Red

Regular priceFrom $80.00
Dark Stallion
Beautiful Behind Butt Plug
Very low stock (1 unit)

Regular price $14.95
Topped Toys
The Grip 115 Plug

(1)

Red Blue
Very low stock (1 unit)

Regular priceFrom $145.00
Topped Toys
Deep Space 90 Plug

Blue Red Obsidian

Regular priceFrom $135.00
Topped Toys
The Grip 106 Plug

Blue Red

Regular priceFrom $125.00
Topped Toys
Chute 85 Plug

Red Blue

Regular priceFrom $100.00
Landco
Maya Vibrating Buttplug

(1)

Regular price $32.95
Topped Toys
The Spike 105 Plug

Blue Red

Regular priceFrom $221.00
Topped Toys
The Grip 134 Plug

Red Blue
Very low stock (1 unit)

Regular priceFrom $195.00
b-Vibe
Vibrating Snug Plug

Regular priceFrom $119.95
Forto
Rattler Plug F-11R

(1)

Black

Regular priceFrom $29.95
Topped Toys
Gape Keeper 128 Plug

Red Blue
Very low stock (1 unit)

Regular priceFrom $215.00
Topped Toys
Chute 100 Plug

Red Blue Obsidian

Regular priceFrom $135.00
Pipedream
Rechargeable Anal Plug

(1)

Regular price $88.95
Oxballs
Stopper Plug

Regular priceFrom $68.95
Spartacus
Beaded Clear Glass Blown Butt Plug
Very low stock (1 unit)

Regular price $39.95
Oxballs
Squirm Butt Plug
Very low stock (1 unit)

Regular price $84.95
Topped Toys
Deep Space 100 Plug

Blue Red Obsidian
Very low stock (1 unit)

Regular priceFrom $155.00
Doc Johnson
American Bombshell Little Boy Butt Plug

Regular price $24.95